Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chet Murthy's avatar

Prof. Delong, I must ask (as a dark-skinned Indian-American who for -decades- used to be surprised when he looked in the mirror and saw a brown guy looking back): Have there ever been any identifiable ethnic groups of dark-skinned immigrants that succeeded in becoming fully-American ? And by that, I mean in the sense that Hannah Arendt underlined when she said "If one is attacked as a Jew, one must defend oneself as a Jew" ?

Because I can't think of one. Black Americans are as -culturally- American as can be: it has been said that "Southern" culture is really just Black culture, only practiced by white Southerners.

And this leads to a depressing conclusion: it's all about the color of skin. Nobody cares about culture: it doesn't matter that to this day I can recite the details of internecine conflicts among the various derivative camps of European constructivist logicians of the late 19th century -- it just doesn't matter. I'm not part of Western Civ, b/c I'm -brown-. Full. Stop.

And Noah is right about "ethnic identity as fundamentally defensive in nature". I don't like Indian food much. I never watch Indian cinema or listen to Indian music. But I wish I did.

sPh's avatar

The most effective force for cultural assimilation in US history was the universal public school system, particularly universal public high schools. 16 year olds will dodge any amount of cultural roadblocks and angry cousins to date a person they find attractive regardless of ethnic group. Of course the hard Radical Right has been working to destroy universal public schooling since 1954; go figure.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?