Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Patrick Brosnan's avatar

'Ernest Renan’s grim lesson about the necessity of historical forgetfulness applies'

Indeed it does if one forgets the formation of the state of Israel in the aftermath of the war and the shocking truth of the holocaust. October 7th was terrible, but not unforeseeable just as the trajectory of Israel's policies towards post-state-establishment settlement would lead to this foreseeable outcome in Gaza. I live in a settler state that refused a reasonable path to reconciliation with the traditional inhabitants just 2 years ago. Much less violent in its aftermath...but psychologically - the scars are deep.

Joe Rousseau's avatar

A terribly profound cross post. And the Ernest Renan quote really is thought provoking.

I’ve been an active foreign policy guy my whole life, but I have to admit that the post 9-11 world has pretty much made me a Middle East neo-isolationist.

Hard enough for a democracy such as ours to craft a longer term “grand strategy” of compromises during “normal” times (where is Dennis Ross these days, anyway?). Now with our much more serious domestic institutional failures … virtually impossible.

I do get a kick out of those who fear China’s “expanding influence” in the region? Really? If Xi wants to grab that hand grenade …. Have at it, Xi.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?