12 Comments

" if the discussion leads to agreement rather than if the discussion leads to the most people holding the correct view as to what would be the optimal decision. "

Pretty much also sums up how we run court cases, doesn't it?

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

There's a saga titled "Rafnkel the Priest of Frey" (spoiler- he loses out in the end). Anyhow, apparently at that time it was quite all right to decide which god of the pantheon treats you best (Frey, in this case), sacrifice to them, and no-one thought ill of you. Sort of a cosmic roulette wheel, with the freedom to change numbers or colors if you thought you got a raw deal.

Expand full comment
author

I thought it was more than quite all right. I thought it was positively encouraged to choose a patron?

Expand full comment

Probably so; I just don't know. Parenthetically, have you ever been to Old Uppsala (not the university town, but the old site a few miles away)? It's spooky to look at those mounds and know that quite possibly, people were hanged from trees on those hills as sacrifices to Frey. Or maybe not.

Expand full comment
author

No. I never have...

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

So what is the function that watching Fox News performs for anyone?

Expand full comment

Similar to the function of going to Church? To keep the juices of religious fervor brewing and to be part of that group experience. (For the church, it is the transfer of wealth to pay for this "valuable service".)

Expand full comment
author

That we are because of who we rile ourselves up to hate?

Expand full comment

Not necessarily. It could be a "Hate Minute" for Goldstein, or a sharing of the same deep emotional state over an idea e.g. rapture over some shared belief. Think of the emotional state of crowds at rallies, sports, bullfights, gladiatorial fights, etc.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

Indeed he did. I have had trouble getting my students to read and absorb Djilas, however. I am not sure why...

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

But why aren't people smart enough to understand that those who have no skin in the game are not reliable?

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

:-)

Expand full comment