15 Comments

Filipowski: Although they could have been rolled out faster, the Trump administration deserves credit for vaccine development and Biden should recognize it. Blame SHOULD go to Trump's CDC which did not give individuals and local decisionmakers the tools and information they needed to avoid unnecessarily costly retractions on activity compared to the benefits of the activity. Likewise, the Trump FDA dragged its feet on promoting cheap rapid screening tests that could have contributed to a more cost-effective response to the pandemic.

Expand full comment

Re: Why Japanese cities are such nice places to live

Has Noah actually lived in cities, or just fallen in love with Tokyo for a short visit? European cities - London, Paris, are layed out just as they are in Tokyo. You can walk down from an apartment to the shop below and be on the main street with shops. If you want. The downsides of this closeness is noise, dirt, smells. It creates a craving (in me at least) for some space, and peace and quiet. After WWII, tract construction of suburbs changed this for many. We traded access for green spaces and quiet. It was the middle class concession to the life of the wealthy - country mansions separated from the hoi polloi and the unpleasantness of the city. People continue to flock to teh cities, but as mary Beard pointed out, in Ancient Rome, the life span of city dwellers was short - disease, murder... Such were the trade offs.

Expand full comment

Re Captain Kirk. I never thought of him that way but I take the point. For me, it was General Patton, at least as portrayed in the film. When I started working, it dawned on me that the guy was a jerk who possibly was suffering from PTSD.

Expand full comment

Delphine Strauss, Sam Fleming, & Valentina Romei:

US productivity growth is not a crisis for Europe. It's not even clear that the reasons for that growth -- good monetary policy and energy independence and notwithstanding a large fiscal deficit -- are directly relevant to Europe.

Expand full comment

Soll: As the Nazi said about “culture,” whenever I hear “industrial policy” I reach for my cost benefit analyzer.

There are good “neo-liberal reasons” to promote investment in activities in which the investor will not receive all of the benefits of the investment such as zero CO2 emitting energy production, storage, and transportation. Likewise, investment in research and development. Likewise, when optimizing the risk of supply disruption by a hostile power is too big a task for any single firm. If we failed to make those investment because someone (“neoliberals?”) insisted on stricter limits on public expenditure than is implicit in making NPV > 0, our bad. If we are now using the NPV > 0 criterion, great.

Why call this return to neoliberal principles “Industrial policy?” And DO all the investment promoted by CHIPS and IRA pass the NPV > 0 test? [Subsidizing INVESTMENT IN zero net CO2 emitting activities instead of the NET CO2 AVOIDED would not appear so.]

And much as we may applaud Alexander Hamilton for advocating for tariffs as a way of taxing slave agriculture exports so that the resources can be used for “internal improvements,” that really is not relevant for today’s debate.

Expand full comment

Ethnonationalism. Now that I live in an area of California that is becoming majority Spanish-speaking, (I don't speak Spanish, nor will I learn at my age), I can get a little irritated when stores use Spanish first for labeling items, or making announcements. But this is very minor. I happily use Google translate if I need to communicate (crudely) with someone who only speaks Spanish, and they with me. [I look forward to cellphones that can detect language and translate speech on the fly in any direction needed. I think we are very close to these ST "Universal Translators".] I have always liked cusines from different countries and cook recipes accordingly. I am happy the better grocery stores have become more diverse in the produce they stock. The internet ensures that my interests are accessible.

If anything, my concerns stem from neighbors with strong right-wing tendencies.

Expand full comment

Meanwhile Charlie Jane Anders is trying to save the next generation (of people), very likely with some real success here and there. While entertaining the rest of us. So I guess that would be "pay it forward."

Expand full comment

“The fact that we only have two hands is not changing rapidly…”

I don't understand the significance. Do we need more hands for some reason?

Expand full comment

While kwetching that Dune is a tragedy, I would point out that the 3 succeeding novels (Dune Messiah, Children of Dune, and Godemperor of Dune), while acknowledging the horror of the billions killed in the Jihad, Leto II sees the only future that preserves humanity from total destruction - the Golden Path. As a result, humanity will scatter across the universe.

Take what message and analysis you want from this, but we have worried about the existential risk of human extinction since 1945. The sources of this risk continue to increase as our knowledge and technology increase.

Expand full comment