11 Comments
author

Thx...

Expand full comment

Noah Smith: "you should know what’s actually happening."

The "conceit" of the educated that people "ought to know"? Spending any time communicating on social media it is quite clear that most people have no idea of what goes on apart from anecdotal information from friends. No amount of presenting data and statistics is accepted - indeed often derided as a "liberal media lies",

The danger is that the assumption that people should be an educated citizenry can result in the old idea that control of the population should be "by their betters". What should be pushed for is finding ways to to get the average person to be able to access real information rather than such [biased] anecdotal information. Unfortunately, we also have pushback against education ("universities brainwash our kids with communist ideas") possibly promulgated by those wishing to maintain their control of the population. It is a tension that in the current state seems difficult to correct.

Expand full comment

Smith/Burn-Murdoch: it's simple; two reasons.

1. The public disbelieves the elites telling them everything is great.

2. The public believes the elites telling them everything is terrible.

Corollary: Public believes that presidents and congresses determine inflation and unemployment.

Expand full comment

From Timothy Snyder: Freedom as a Value and a Task - a Talk in Kyiv https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LkXsW14qJQ

"I believe that freedom is a meta-value, because there are real values in the world ... honesty, generosity, loyalty are real ... maybe not in the same way as a rock is real, but no less real than a rock ... and therefore freedom is not a value like other values, freedom is a value because it's the thing that allows us to make decisions among the other values. So ... loyalty and honesty are good but they don't always go together. For example, as you get older, when people say 'you look great', it takes on a different significance; it's shifting from honesty to loyalty - but it's not both. In a friendship, sometimes you're loyal, and sometimes you're honest, but if you're free, you're thinking about which one and in which combination." [At this point he acknowledges the influence of his teacher Leszek Kolakowski.]

Audience Question [paraphrase] Are *all* the Russians responsible for this war? Those who actively support it, those who passively support it, and those who take part? But everyone knows that Putin is a dictator, and dictatorship means that people have no freedom ... if [Russians] are not free, you can think that they bear no responsibility for the situation ... I do believe they are responsible, but help me [reconcile this contradiction.]

Snyder's answer to that question was very interesting.

Expand full comment

re: Jonathan Kirshner: Rigged Capitalism and the Rise of Pluto-Populism: On Martin Wolf’s “The Crisis of Democratic Capitalism”

I rather liked this article putting our current situation in some historical perspective.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/19/opinion/rich-billionaires-philanthropy-covid.html

Expand full comment

Re: Ezra Klein: Interview with Casey Newton & Kevin Roose

Cory Doctorrow has a more interesting take on this "kerfuffle": The Real AI Fight https://pluralistic.net/2023/11/27/10-types-of-people/

Expand full comment

Jürgen Osterhammel & Patrick Camiller: And to obtain benefits smaller than available from free trade. :)

Expand full comment

Kirshner: It does not do so without the help of another party not dedicated to policies of inclusive growth: taxation to reduce deficits, merit-based immigration, low-cost measures to address climate change, cost benefit vetted regulation, smart globalization.

Expand full comment

Belello: But will it be in time to avoid recession? Or is this an expectation of a reaction TO recession?

Expand full comment